Expensive Quentin,

My spouse and I’ve been collectively for 11 years. We’ve twins aged 2, and I’ve a 20-year-old son in faculty.  I’ve my very own enterprise and do nicely.  I’m 59 and my spouse is 33. 

I paid the condominium lease for 10 years for her mother. I additionally paid my mother-in-law $1,600 monthly for serving to with our twins for one yr.  As well as, my spouse employed her for a yr in a salon. Neither occupation ended nicely resulting from her mother’s want to push again on her daughter’s authority.

My spouse has two siblings. One has little or no, whereas the opposite has no children and a pleasant enterprise — but he has by no means contributed to his mother’s bills.  Additionally, my mother-in-law doesn’t search work, however she does breed canine, which gives some earnings. 

As I strategy 60, I’ve defined that I cannot be signing any lease subsequent yr (January) and that I’ll contribute as much as $500 monthly in lease, however the the rest should come from the mother and her brother. 

Whereas everybody agrees, no motion or additional efforts have been made by anybody and I’m involved that come fall, amnesia will kick in, and I will probably be on one other lease and caught with the lease once more.

I’ve three children and a spouse in faculty as nicely, and wish to chop the wire.

What do you recommend?

59-year-old Son-in-Regulation

Expensive Son-in-Regulation,

You don’t need to handle your mother-in-law’s expectations or, for that matter, her direct deposits. You solely have to handle your individual.

Typically, one of the simplest ways to get the end result you want is to take the trail of least resistance and do nothing. Maybe your mother-in-law and her kids are busily planning to signal a brand new lease and agree on how the lease must be paid. Maybe they’re counting on the “if it’s not damaged, don’t repair it” precept, and benignly ready for the direct deposit to proceed.

As Jane Austen wrote in “Persuasion” (1817), “Allow us to by no means underestimate the ability of a well-written letter.” Remind your mother-in-law of the final date of the lease, and inform her you’ll preserve her within the loop on the brand new association in writing. Inform the owner that the funds will finish on the final date of the lease, and cc your mother-in-law on the letter.

It could really feel tough to set a bar in your generosity, after which regulate that after a number of years. Nevertheless it seems like you’ve tried a number of methods of serving to your mother-in-law, and none of them has labored out, by means of no fault of your individual. She has labored in your spouse’s salon, she has been compensated for serving to together with your twins, and you’ve got adopted that up by protecting her lease.

You are actually flexing a brand new muscle. When you draw a line within the sand and keep on with it, it can get simpler the subsequent time you do it. And the subsequent.

You’ll be able to e-mail The Moneyist with any monetary and moral questions associated to coronavirus at [email protected], and comply with Quentin Fottrell on Twitter.

By emailing your questions, you conform to having them printed anonymously on MarketWatch. By submitting your story to Dow Jones & Firm, the writer of MarketWatch, you perceive and agree that we could use your story, or variations of it, in all media and platforms, together with through third events.

Try the Moneyist private Facebook 

group, the place we search for solutions to life’s thorniest cash points. Readers write in to me with all kinds of dilemmas. Publish your questions, inform me what you need to know extra about, or weigh in on the newest Moneyist columns.

Extra from Quentin Fottrell:


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here